Titans Secure the No. 1 Pick: The Shedeur Sanders vs. Travis Hunter Debate Begins

The Tennessee Titans have vaulted into the top spot of the 2025 NFL Draft after a tumultuous season that ended with a loss to the Houston Texans and a surprising win by the New England Patriots over the Buffalo Bills in Week 18. With the No. 1 pick officially in hand, the debate is already heating up: Should the Titans select Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders or his two-way superstar teammate, Travis Hunter?

Tennessee’s glaring need at quarterback has been evident throughout the season. Will Levis struggled with accuracy and showed an inability to handle pressure, leaving the Titans in search of a long-term solution at the game’s most important position. Shedeur Sanders has been one of the most talked-about prospects, but questions linger about whether he’s truly worth the top overall selection. Some analysts argue his hype outpaces his production, and just last week, a draft expert on The Rich Eisen Show noted that Sanders wasn’t even projected as a first-round pick earlier this season.

For those doubting Sanders, Miami’s Cam Ward has emerged as another potential candidate for QB1. Ward’s combination of arm strength, mobility, and poise has led some to suggest he’s the better prospect compared to Sanders. If the Titans were to pass on Ward for Sanders, it could be viewed as a significant gamble—or even a mistake.

Meanwhile, Travis Hunter’s name is also in the mix. The Heisman Trophy-winning wide receiver and cornerback is a generational talent who can transform a team on both sides of the ball. However, selecting a non-quarterback with the first overall pick always comes with risks, especially for a team like Tennessee that lacks stability at quarterback.

Adding intrigue to the situation, Shedeur Sanders’ father and head coach, Deion Sanders, has openly stated he will be selective about where his son plays at the next level. The Titans’ recent struggles, lackluster offensive line, and questionable roster depth could make them a less-than-ideal destination for Shedeur. The question looms: Would Coach Prime and Shedeur be willing to say “no” to Tennessee?

The Titans face a monumental decision as they evaluate their options. Do they bet on Shedeur Sanders to be their franchise quarterback, consider the raw but promising Cam Ward, or opt for the once-in-a-lifetime talent of Travis Hunter? With the clock ticking toward draft day, Tennessee’s choice could define the future of the franchise for years to come.