Broncos Trading Patrick Surtain II for JJ McCarthy in 2024 NFL Draft?

As the 2024 NFL Draft approaches, the Denver Broncos, under the helm of head coach Sean Payton, are considering a bold strategy to secure their quarterback of the future. Amid swirling speculations, Payton appears poised to take a significant gamble, potentially involving star cornerback Patrick Surtain in a trade package to move up for JJ McCarthy.

The prospect of acquiring McCarthy, touted as one of the top quarterback prospects in the draft class, has ignited discussions within the Broncos organization. Payton, known for his strategic acumen and daring moves, sees McCarthy as a transformative figure who could reshape the team’s quarterback situation.

One proposed scenario involves leveraging this year’s first-round pick, a future first-rounder, and the prized asset of Patrick Surtain to entice the Arizona Cardinals, who hold the fourth overall pick. The Broncos believe that Arizona would be inclined to entertain such a lucrative offer, positioning Denver to secure McCarthy’s services.

Alternatively, if the trade for McCarthy proves unattainable, the Broncos may pivot towards a strategy of moving down in the draft. Payton and his team recognize the importance of securing a franchise quarterback, prioritizing the acquisition of McCarthy over retaining an elite cornerback like Surtain, particularly on a team facing challenges.

The underlying philosophy driving the Broncos’ approach underscores the high stakes involved in quarterback acquisitions. While Surtain’s value is undeniable, Payton and company believe that investing in McCarthy or a comparable quarterback prospect is paramount for the team’s long-term success.

However, the decision to pursue McCarthy comes with inherent risks. As with any rookie quarterback, there are no guarantees of success, and the potential for bust looms large. Payton and the Broncos are acutely aware of the ramifications of such a move, recognizing that a misstep could set the team back significantly.

Ultimately, the Broncos face a pivotal juncture in their quest for quarterback stability. Whether they opt for the bold maneuver to secure McCarthy or exercise caution in their approach, the upcoming draft promises to shape the team’s trajectory for years to come. For Sean Payton and the Broncos, the decision will hinge on striking the delicate balance between risk and reward in their pursuit of JJ McCarthy.